Best Property Managers
in Birmingham

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Birmingham.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated October 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Atlas Rental Property
2015 3rd Ave N Ste 100, Birmingham, AL 35203
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
90.00
2 Neighborhood Management, LLC
2700 US-280 #425w, Birmingham, AL 35223
Property Pro
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.2
89.12
3 PMI Birmingham Region
321 Applegate Pkwy Ste C, Pelham, AL 35124
Trusted Partner
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
88.66
4 Evernest Property Management Birmingham
1 Independence Plaza Suite 620, Birmingham, AL 352...
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
86.00
5 America's Rental Managers
3829 Lorna Rd #302, Birmingham, AL 35244
Property Manager
★ ★ ★ ☆ ☆
3.9
82.54

Expert Reviews

Atlas Rental Property
Property Management
1
Atlas Rental Property
90.00
Authority
2015 3rd Ave N Ste 100, Birmingham, AL 35203

Atlas Rental Property manages residential units in Birmingham. The company’s property management team includes Simone Harris, who provides thorough responses to tenant inquiries. Tae, another team member, offers efficient repairs and clear explanations of his work, including a window replacement.

Anthony, a maintenance technician associated with Atlas Rental Property, has been noted for his professional and detailed approach to tasks such as mold remediation. His work has been described as thorough, addressing issues with care and precision. He has been requested for subsequent service due to the quality of his past work.

The property management’s handling of repairs, particularly concerning a driveway’s usability and safety for residents, has been a point of concern. Issues with the driveway’s condition, which have persisted over several months, have led to vehicle damage and safety hazards for residents, including a grandchild. The accessibility of the property has become a significant challenge.

Neighborhood Management, LLC
Property Pro
2
Neighborhood Management, LLC
89.12
Authority
2700 US-280 #425w, Birmingham, AL 35223

Neighborhood Management, LLC oversees properties in areas such as Liberty Park. During a recent transition to manage a new neighborhood, residents encountered initial setup challenges with amenity and payment portals. Betsy provided immediate assistance, correcting information and smoothing the onboarding process for new homeowners.

The company's responsiveness to property upkeep is evident in their management of the Liberty Park back gate. Repairs to this frequently damaged gate are consistently completed within hours of an incident. This prompt attention to recurring issues addresses a specific property maintenance concern.

In terms of customer interaction, April Herrik is noted for her assistance with website registration and payment. She guided a frustrated resident through the online payment system, which was not straightforward, ensuring timely submission of dues. April's approach was described as warm, considerate, and patient.

PMI Birmingham Region
Trusted Partner
3
PMI Birmingham Region
88.66
Authority
321 Applegate Pkwy Ste C, Pelham, AL 35124

PMI Birmingham Region offers property management services from their Pelham, AL office. The company's team is noted for its availability and straightforward communication. For instance, inquiries about vendor management, collection efforts, and financial oversight have been met with clear and concise explanations.

Client interactions often highlight specific individuals within the organization. Trey Rayburn is frequently mentioned for his helpfulness and dependability, making himself available when needed. Similarly, Ethan Miller has been recognized for his professionalism and consistent follow-through on projects, ensuring all aspects are addressed.

The firm's capacity to resolve issues and provide vendor recommendations is a recurring theme in client feedback. One resident noted Blaine's assistance in solving community issues and offering guidance on quality vendors for household problems.

Evernest Property Management Birmingham
Property Management
4
Evernest Property Management Birmingham
86.00
Authority
1 Independence Plaza Suite 620, Birmingham, AL 35209

Evernest Property Management in Birmingham operates from 1 Independence Plaza. The team's responsiveness during the leasing and move-in phases stands out. Ken addressed inquiries quickly following the initial move-in, and Jason ensured the property was prepared. Tamara provided recommendations and maintained prompt communication regarding rental availability.

During property inspections, staff like Carlton have been noted for their courtesy. He contacted the resident in advance of an annual inspection and explained the process before beginning. He also reviewed specific issues found upon completion, a departure from a more common, less communicative approach.

The company's approach to customer interaction, as exemplified by Tamara's efforts to match requirements with available homes, focuses on ongoing client needs. This customer-oriented engagement has been observed even when an initial property inquiry did not proceed.

America's Rental Managers
Property Manager
5
America's Rental Managers
82.54
Authority
3829 Lorna Rd #302, Birmingham, AL 35244

America's Rental Managers oversees a broad portfolio of properties in Birmingham. The company’s inventory includes recently constructed homes, some of which have featured yard maintenance requiring significant resident attention upon move-in. Reports note instances of uneven landscaping and issues with paint durability.

The application and rental process has been described as straightforward by some residents. Specific staff members, including Michael Glass and Preston Burks, have been recognized for their informative and helpful interactions. Responsiveness to resident concerns has been noted, with issues typically addressed within a reasonable timeframe.

The company manages rental agreements for multiple properties, with some tenants renewing leases and expressing satisfaction with the selection and pricing relative to area apartments. For individuals seeking rental housing, the breadth of available homes is a noted characteristic of America's Rental Managers.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Birmingham

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Birmingham?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Birmingham Real Estate Agents