Best Property Managers in
Arizona

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Arizona to find the absolute elite Property Managers destinations.

Average Authority Score
67.3
across all ranked locations
Top-Rated City
Mesa
highest avg. score in Arizona
Verified Locations
73
businesses confirmed active
Cities Ranked
4
Phoenix · Tucson · Mesa · Glendale

Arizona Hall of Fame

On Q Property Management
State Elite
1
On Q Property Management
97.00
Authority
1011 N Val Vista Dr #101, Gilbert, AZ 85234

On Q Property Management handles tenant inquiries and property maintenance. The team has been noted for prompt responses to repair requests, with one resident recalling a quick resolution for a household issue and assistance in finding a pest control service. During lease renewal walk-throughs, individuals like Russell provided thorough and considerate service, managing the process efficiently even when residents required rest.

The company’s leasing agents have been recognized for their support of new renters. Tara DeRaps, for example, guided a first-time renter through the process with patience and clarity, ensuring they felt informed and comfortable. Nick assisted a family in locating and moving into a suitable home quickly, addressing all questions and maintaining momentum throughout the transaction. Nathan also received commendation for his customer service and responsiveness.

Conversely, a tenant reported significant unresolved issues in their rented unit, including non-working keys at move-in, a prolonged drainage problem leading to pest concerns, and a malfunctioning dishwasher and washer. Further complications arose from water damage and mold, with the property undergoing extensive restoration. This tenant cited inconsistent communication and a lack of accountability regarding rent charges during the period the unit was uninhabitable.

Stratton Vantage Property Management
State Elite
2
Stratton Vantage Property Management
94.00
Authority
3635 E Inverness Ave Ste 101, Mesa, AZ 85206

Stratton Vantage Property Management's handling of a tenant's AC issues involved multiple technician visits with no resolution for the duration of the summer heat. Following these visits, the tenants were charged $150 for the service calls. The company's communication during this period included a technician who conveyed to the tenants' pregnant wife that while they were usually low priority, her condition would expedite the process, yet a resolution was not immediate.

Regarding appliance repairs, a washer issue persisted for six weeks despite the tenants following a technician's recommended cleaning protocol. Stratton Vantage eventually informed the tenants that the appliance was considered a "convenience" and the owner opted not to repair it. Consequently, the tenants incurred the cost of purchasing and installing their own replacement machine. Three days after this, their lease was not renewed, and they faced a $150 charge for the technician visit, which Stratton Vantage claimed was due to the machine "working as designed."

Tenants interacting with Stratton Vantage Property Management reported inconsistent information, missing documentation, incomplete email responses, and a general lack of proactive updates. The firm stated their primary role was to act on the owner's instructions, directing tenants to resolve disputes directly with the owner, which contradicted their website's FAQ regarding landlord responsibilities for repairs. Notably, the tenants' experience at 3635 E Inverness Ave Ste 101, Mesa, AZ 85206 did not align with the FAQ's assertion that landlords are responsible for repairs beyond tenant damage or routine items.

Brown Community Management
State Elite
3
Brown Community Management
92.50
Authority
7255 E Hampton Ave Ste 101, Mesa, AZ 85209

Brown Community Management handles property management for several communities in Mesa. Their Senior Community Manager, Becca Canter, has assisted homeowners with resolving rental management issues and answering questions about HOA dues. Another manager, Kathrine Hughes, has been noted for her responsiveness; she has been available on weekdays, including the morning after a holiday, and even came off of paid time off to assist with a property owner's need for roof access codes.

Mashell Frost, working from the Mesa office, addressed a homeowner's concerns regarding HOA fee payments. Frost provided clarity on why payments were not processing and remained patient and pleasant while explaining the situation. She gathered necessary information to resolve the problem and followed up until the issue was fully rectified. Mashell has also been recognized for her detailed account analysis, her initiative in contacting other parties for clarification, and her clear communication regarding account discrepancies and address changes.

In one instance, a homeowner faced difficulties with their HOA, citing a lack of community amenities and maintenance. This resident expressed dissatisfaction with landscaping services not being performed as agreed upon and the removal of original shrubbery without replacement. The communication with the HOA was described as unhelpful, with a focus on payment collection and the threat of liens, leading to additional attorney fees for disputes over service quality.

Blue Fox Properties LLC
State Elite
4
Blue Fox Properties LLC
91.00
Authority
7368 N La Cholla Blvd, Tucson, AZ 85741

Blue Fox Properties LLC in Tucson guides property owners through their holdings with a structured approach. The company's onboarding team, including Natalia and Sylvia White, has been noted for detailing a property's advantages and disadvantages. They provide counsel and maintain consistent updates throughout the management process.

The firm's operational methods have been described as formal and organized, with an emphasis on clear and prompt communication. This procedural definition allows clients to understand expected outcomes. For out-of-state landlords, their system of management has proven beneficial, with individuals like Amanda A. assisting with tenant-related issues and repairs.

Tenants renting properties managed by Blue Fox have reported a smooth end-to-end experience, from occupancy to vacating. The team, which has included Jaime, is recognized for professionalism and responsiveness. Their technology supports property management functions such as rent collection and maintenance requests, which can include photo uploads for immediate submission.

Home Ladder Property Management
State Elite
5
Home Ladder Property Management
90.61
Authority
3303 E Baseline Rd #119, Gilbert, AZ 85234

Home Ladder Property Management addresses rental applications with a streamlined process. Christy Holmes is noted for her thorough guidance during the rental application and move-in phases, ensuring all resident needs are met. This includes addressing required maintenance in a prompt and professional manner.

Jessica and the Home Ladder team manage investment properties by placing tenants efficiently, often working within budgetary constraints. They maintain consistent communication with property owners regarding their homes and the residents within them.

The company's approach to property turnovers, as observed by external service providers, shows a dedication to the upkeep of residences. This includes a focus on the quality of the living environment and the resident experience.

City Directory

Switch to Real Estate Agents in Arizona

We also track and rank the top real estate agents providers across Arizona.

View Arizona Real Estate Agents