Best Property Managers in
Indiana

T&H Realty Services, Inc. manages properties at 760 E 52nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46205. Manager Marcella Murray addressed property concerns, providing thorough communication and support. Kristina Swatts assisted with investment criteria, visiting properties and providing feedback over nine months.

Maintenance issues have been addressed with varying degrees of success. One tenant reported a contractor, Corbin Whitney, was punctual and repaired gutters promptly. Another tenant experienced prolonged delays with a leak, requiring them to turn off the main water supply for days and ultimately paying for unaddressed repairs.

For property owners, T&H Realty has been with for nearly a decade. The company maintains clear communication, handles property upkeep, and issues financial statements and disbursements in a timely manner. This systematic approach has led to minimal owner involvement in property management.

Red Door Property Management handles rental properties in Indianapolis, with an office at 3815 River Crossing Pkwy #100. They have managed properties where tenants reported issues previously unaddressed by prior management groups. Maintenance requests are submitted easily, and responses for repairs are timely.

One tenant recalled a flooding incident in a crawl space due to a broken water softener. Red Door responded rapidly to this issue, completing necessary repairs. They also provided a rent credit to offset a high water bill resulting from the flooding.

The management company oversees properties described by their listings. One visitor noted that a rental property was "everything the listing said it would be," serving as a suitable gathering place for family. The back porch was highlighted as a location for viewing sunsets.

Keyrenter Indianapolis North Property Management, located at 38 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032, offers a structured approach to property oversight. Their team, including individuals like Adam and Stephanie, works with clients on onboarding and ongoing management tasks. The company facilitated digital completion for a straightforward move-in process.

The company has engaged with out-of-state investors, with Zach providing property analysis and recommendations. Adam is also noted for his involvement in these investor relations. This suggests a focus on guiding clients through the initial investment and placement phases of rental properties.

For existing property owners, Keyrenter has managed renovations with budget considerations and coordinated a full suite of services from cleaning and repairs to marketing, showings, and tenant screening. Communication and accessibility are consistent themes, with the owner portal offering a centralized system for tracking financial and maintenance data.

PMI Indianapolis manages properties from its Noblesville office. Aiko Shosaku, in Resident Support, assisted a resident with portal issues and move-out arrangements that had been pending for months. Shosaku addressed web problems and provided answers regarding move-out, with follow-up communication the next day. Carmie, an account representative, has also been cited for her consistent patience and politeness when addressing resident concerns.

Residents have reported instances of prolonged communication delays following significant property damage, such as a burst water heater. In one account, a week passed without updates on the replacement of a water heater and flooring after a flood. While the water heater was eventually replaced, the flooring was not, leading to warping.

Communication with the main office has been described by some as difficult, with a lack of willingness to resolve issues. One resident noted that their apartment complex has declined in appearance since PMI Indianapolis took over management.

Intrigue Real Estate & Property Management is located at 350 Massachusetts Ave #300 in Indianapolis. For investors managing properties from afar, Ryan has provided a candid perspective on Indianapolis market strategies, drawing on his experience as an investor and the knowledge of his established team. His discussions have included specifics on deal structures, neighborhood dynamics, and renovation economics.

Wes has assisted clients with specific property issues, such as addressing water heater problems. He responded promptly to inquiries and offered detailed explanations until the issue was resolved. This approach helped to ease a potentially stressful situation for the client.

Richard Vinson has been noted for providing thoughtful and pertinent advice to out-of-state investors. His management style has been described as attentive to client issues and inquiries, leading to minimal problems with properties under his care. This allowed for consistent monthly payments for property owners.