Best Property Managers
in Orem

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Orem.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated October 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Red Sign Real Estate Team
998 N 1200 W, Orem, UT 84057
Property Pro
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
95.00
2 Nestwell Property Management
8813 S Redwood Rd Ste D1, West Jordan, UT 84088
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
93.00
3 Harman Property Management Group
73 W University Pkwy, Orem, UT 84058
Property Managers
★ ★ ★ ☆ ☆
3.9
80.73
4 Prime Time Property Management
1145 S 800 E #110, Orem, UT 84058
Trusted Service
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
78.69
5 PMI Made Simple
1145 S 800 E #110, Orem, UT 84097
Property Manager
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.0
78.43

Expert Reviews

Red Sign Real Estate Team
Property Pro
1
Red Sign Real Estate Team
95.00
Authority
998 N 1200 W, Orem, UT 84057

The Red Sign Real Estate Team works with clients at 998 N 1200 W, Orem, UT 84057. They assisted one family relocating from out of state by dedicating a week to lining up showings across Utah, accommodating frequent changes in their preferences. For another client, Caroline spent several years assisting them in finding suitable housing.

The team's involvement in property transactions extended to managing sales, with one account detailing a house sold quickly and at a higher-than-expected price while the seller was relocating to another state. Colby and Trevor were noted for their close contact and understanding during this process.

For clients seeking to purchase their first home, Michael Judd offered guidance and answered questions throughout the process. Another agent, Kim, handled the marketing of a property and kept the seller informed at every stage.

Nestwell Property Management
Property Management
2
Nestwell Property Management
93.00
Authority
8813 S Redwood Rd Ste D1, West Jordan, UT 84088

Nestwell Property Management faces varied feedback regarding its operational efficiency. Instances were reported of a rocky start for some clients, including a situation where a property advertised as pet-friendly later had restrictions, leading to a need to reapply after paying an application fee. There were also reports of canceled and rescheduled showings. However, after securing a suitable property, the experience improved, with one tenant noting a particularly positive interaction with an agent named Max, who was described as warm, professional, patient, and thorough in explaining the move-in process.

Concerns have been raised about financial oversight and vendor management. One owner detailed significant discrepancies between billed maintenance work and actual completion, with charges appearing to be inflated and requiring owner intervention to adjust. Similar issues arose with a washing machine repair, where a diagnosis fee was charged despite the appliance functioning correctly. HOA payments were also delayed, and owner statements included charges for services that were not rendered or were inappropriate for the property type, such as yard care on an HOA-managed property. Communication issues were also noted, with outsourced customer care and a perceived slow response to legitimate tenant issues contrasted with prompt attention to charges and fees.

Tenant experiences also highlight communication challenges and repair delays. Several renters reported unreturned calls and generic email responses instead of direct communication, particularly when trying to resolve issues. Repairs for a cracked window and a broken microwave vent cover took approximately two months. One tenant noted their rent was withdrawn automatically without prior agreement, requiring weeks to rectify. Issues also arose at the end of leases, with attempts to charge for unleased periods and the addition of questionable post-lease fees.

Harman Property Management Group
Property Managers
3
Harman Property Management Group
80.73
Authority
73 W University Pkwy, Orem, UT 84058

Harman Property Management Group in Orem provides property management services. Initial rental inquiries can involve Katelynn Bright, noted for scheduling tours and explaining policies during the approval process, even for out-of-state applicants. Property owners may receive comprehensive quarterly reports detailing property performance and updates.

Maintenance and community relations appear to be areas of focus for some managers. Stephanie is mentioned for her work with maintenance staff, which has coincided with improved community attitudes towards the property and its upkeep.

Conversely, some former tenants have reported significant communication issues, describing interactions as demanding and confrontational. Concerns were also raised about unexpected fees, unannounced property visits, and general disorganization leading to missed appointments and rescheduling.

Prime Time Property Management
Trusted Service
4
Prime Time Property Management
78.69
Authority
1145 S 800 E #110, Orem, UT 84058

Prime Time Property Management offers services from their Orem location at 1145 S 800 E #110. Bret, a representative of the company, assists clients with property transactions, including buying and selling homes. His approach involves proactive communication and an awareness of client interests.

The firm's operations extend to property management for rental units. A year-long tenancy with Prime Time saw maintenance requests addressed with speed. Communication about property matters is a noted aspect of their client interactions.

Bret has also managed estate sales, providing visibility for properties. He handled the specifics of a home sale, working through logistical details for clients located elsewhere. The sales process, from initial listing to closing, was managed with attention to the intricacies involved.

PMI Made Simple
Property Manager
5
PMI Made Simple
78.43
Authority
1145 S 800 E #110, Orem, UT 84097

PMI Made Simple, located at 1145 S 800 E #110, Orem, UT 84097, has been noted for significant delays in addressing tenant concerns. Multiple reports indicate that responses to tenant inquiries can take upwards of a week, impacting essential matters such as move-in codes and appliance repairs. One resident recounted a situation where a forgotten move-in code left them stranded for hours with their belongings. Similarly, another tenant experienced a two-month delay in floor repairs following a basement flood.

The company's handling of property readiness and ongoing maintenance has also drawn criticism. Prospective tenants have cited receiving units with structural damage, pests, and incomplete installations, such as promised blinds that remain unaddressed for months. Requests for essential services, including trash removal, reportedly required formal action to be resolved. Issues with plumbing, water heaters, and HVAC systems have been reported shortly after move-in.

In some instances, tenants have faced difficulties obtaining necessary documentation for vital assistance programs. Delays in providing simple verification forms, even when submitted in person and followed up on repeatedly, have led to the closure of tenant benefits. Beyond the operational challenges, there are accounts of significant financial disputes upon move-out, with former residents alleging substantial charges for issues that predated their tenancy or were not adequately maintained by the management.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Orem

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Orem?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Orem Real Estate Agents