Best Property Managers
in Newport News

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Newport News.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated September 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 RedSail Property Management
735 Thimble Shoals Blvd #130, Newport News, VA 236...
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
92.88
2 Real Property Management Tidal
780 Pilot House Dr #400D, Newport News, VA 23606
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
82.35
3 KRS Holdings
5 W Queens Wy #102, Hampton, VA 23669
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
81.42
4 Liz Moore & Associates Property Management
4365 New Town Ave, Williamsburg, VA 23188
Property Managers
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
77.34
5 Heritage Home Property Management
6632 George Washington Memorial Hwy, Yorktown, VA...
Trusted Managers
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
74.63

Expert Reviews

RedSail Property Management
Property Management
1
RedSail Property Management
92.88
Authority
735 Thimble Shoals Blvd #130, Newport News, VA 23606

RedSail Property Management's operations at 735 Thimble Shoals Blvd #130 in Newport News present a complex picture for property owners. In one instance, a property owner cited a six-month delay in notification regarding flooding damage originating from a renter, impacting drywall in multiple areas. This same owner also reported discrepancies in paint application for repairs, with gloss white appearing on a flat white ceiling, a deviation from the standards previously imposed for rental.

The company's tenant qualification process has also drawn scrutiny. One potential renter noted a requirement for income three times the monthly rent per applicant, deeming it excessive for a property valued at $1695 per month. Another applicant described challenges in securing a virtual tour for a property due to the company's stated limitations with digital tools, leading to a perception of miscommunication regarding application status and property availability.

Conversely, some tenancies have reported a more positive interaction. One reviewer specifically mentioned RedSail Property Management's effectiveness in addressing issues promptly and efficiently, contributing to a favorable rental experience.

Real Property Management Tidal
Property Management
2
Real Property Management Tidal
82.35
Authority
780 Pilot House Dr #400D, Newport News, VA 23606

Real Property Management Tidal in Newport News handles property management with a focus on consistent operations. Mark Gregory has been noted for his promptness and thoroughness in tenant screening, coordinating repairs, and minimizing vacancy periods. Anthony is recognized for his diligence in maintenance duties and polite communication. The staff, in general, responds promptly and works to resolve issues that arise.

The company maintains operations over extended periods, even through management changes. They possess a capacity for knowing when to initiate contact and formulating relevant inquiries. Requests are met with attentiveness, and detailed answers are pursued when immediate clarity is absent.

There are instances where timely disbursement of funds is not met, and the correct amounts are not consistently transferred. Communication regarding issues, specifically with Karen, can be slow, lacking even acknowledgment of receipt. This has led to a need for in-person visits to the office for resolution.

KRS Holdings
Property Management
3
KRS Holdings
81.42
Authority
5 W Queens Wy #102, Hampton, VA 23669

KRS Holdings manages properties from their Newport News office at 5 W Queens Wy #102. David Shears from KRS Holdings assisted a client with AC repairs, demonstrating a timely and professional approach alongside a helpful demeanor. Another client reported a technician named Stanley spent approximately two hours addressing an issue with dedication and thoroughness, ensuring all work was completed correctly.

Maintenance work at a rented property involved Andre addressing multiple issues shortly after the tenant moved in. Andre’s approach was described as quick, professional, and neat, with clear communication regarding problems and resolutions. He is noted for his skill and precision in resolving all reported concerns.

However, one account details significant maintenance failures, including a sewage flood that was addressed with temporary fixes rather than permanent repairs to ancient piping. This tenant also reported issues with unaddressed trash left on the property and a lack of clear information regarding contractors. The account also mentions discrepancies between property photos and the actual condition upon rental, along with concerns about upfront costs and charges even after professional cleaning.

Liz Moore & Associates Property Management
Property Managers
4
Liz Moore & Associates Property Management
77.34
Authority
4365 New Town Ave, Williamsburg, VA 23188

Liz Moore & Associates Property Management, located at 4365 New Town Ave, Williamsburg, VA 23188, handles property management services. Initial client experiences highlight prompt callbacks and efficient showings, with one individual noting immediate assistance upon relocation from out of state. The company's representatives are described as maintaining consistent communication and support throughout client transitions.

Personnel like Monica Schrum and Allison are specifically mentioned for their consistent attention to detail and proactive communication. Clients have reported their property managers addressing questions, coordinating requests, and resolving unexpected issues with thoroughness. This level of service extends to providing assurance for property owners regarding their assets.

The firm's approach includes a focus on facilitating smooth transitions, even when encountering unforeseen circumstances. References are made to connecting individuals with appropriate resources during stressful situations, such as issues with lenders. The company's agents are characterized by their professionalism and attentiveness throughout the property management process.

Heritage Home Property Management
Trusted Managers
5
Heritage Home Property Management
74.63
Authority
6632 George Washington Memorial Hwy, Yorktown, VA 23692

Heritage Home Property Management, located at 6632 George Washington Memorial Hwy in Yorktown, VA, offers property management services in the Newport News area. Silas and Taylor, the principals, have transitioned from real estate to property management, bringing with them a known quantity of expertise.

Their approach to managing rental properties is noted for its efficiency and professionalism, particularly for owners residing out of state. The management process is described as seamless, with the team handling day-to-day operations and involving owners only for essential decisions. This model allows for a hands-off ownership experience for clients.

The company's ability to maintain properties extends to having established connections with contractors for any necessary repairs or upkeep. Communication is consistently described as clear and proactive, fostering a sense of security for property owners.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Newport News

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Newport News?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Newport News Real Estate Agents