Best Property Managers
in Green Bay

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Green Bay.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated October 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Wisconsin Discount Properties
1240 Main St, Green Bay, WI 54302
Trusted Partner
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
84.28
2 Blue Frog Property Management
1960 August St, Green Bay, WI 54302
Avoid
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
82.05
3 Badgerland Vacation Homes
1382 Bucky's Run, Green Bay, WI 54313
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
80.58
4 Alliance Management
2563 Development Dr, Green Bay, WI 54311
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.3
79.17
5 Legacy First, LLC
304 N Adams St Ste 1, Green Bay, WI 54301
Trusted Advisor
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
78.05

Expert Reviews

Wisconsin Discount Properties
Trusted Partner
1
Wisconsin Discount Properties
84.28
Authority
1240 Main St, Green Bay, WI 54302

Wisconsin Discount Properties, located at 1240 Main St, Green Bay, WI 54302, facilitates transactions for individuals seeking investment properties in the Green Bay and Fox Valley areas. The firm has a consistent record of providing off-market deals. Reese and Connor are noted individuals within the organization who manage client interactions.

Clients have reported that transactions managed by Wisconsin Discount Properties proceed smoothly from initial engagement through to closing. Reese has been highlighted for his consistent communication, both during the acquisition process and following the finalization of a property transfer. This approach has been described as simplifying the purchase of multiple investment properties.

Guidance and education are integral to the client experience at Wisconsin Discount Properties. The team assists individuals, including those new to real estate investing, with understanding the acquisition process and bid estimations. Clients have found that the firm's advertised property information aligns with the actual condition of the properties, fostering a high level of trust in their dealings.

Blue Frog Property Management
Avoid
2
Blue Frog Property Management
82.05
Authority
1960 August St, Green Bay, WI 54302

Blue Frog Property Management operates at 1960 August St, Green Bay, WI 54302. Communications regarding repairs were not readily available, with requests becoming convoluted and difficult to file correctly. The process of receiving a security deposit involved extended delays and required explicit explanation of legal statutes concerning timely returns, with an eventual delivery occurring two weeks after the mandated period. Charges for full replacement of items were levied without explanation.

Interaction with the company proved challenging. Attempts to communicate via phone, email, and voice message were frequently met with no response. An appointment was scheduled for a walk-in to discuss issues, only for the company to subsequently state they were no longer accepting walk-ins. Yearly inspections were reportedly conducted, however, significant issues discovered during move-out were not identified during these alleged inspections.

There are reports of significant neglect, including the painting over of black mold rather than addressing it, and the presence of pests. Utility charges were questioned due to a substantial discrepancy from expected amounts, leading to a protracted dispute. Some interactions with staff were described as rude, with requests for assistance perceived as inconveniences.

Badgerland Vacation Homes
Property Management
3
Badgerland Vacation Homes
80.58
Authority
1382 Bucky's Run, Green Bay, WI 54313

Badgerland Vacation Homes manages properties at 1382 Bucky's Run in Green Bay, Wisconsin. The management company’s point of contact, Josh, has been noted for his prompt and reliable communication with both property owners and guests. He handles inquiries and daily operations with professionalism, ensuring a smooth experience for all parties involved.

Stellar Cleaning Services observed an increase in bookings after Badgerland Vacation Homes took over management of their associated properties. This suggests a focused approach to occupancy and guest acquisition. Josh maintains open communication with partners, keeping them informed and facilitating consistent work.

One guest mentioned Josh’s attentiveness during their stay at an Airbnb property. He provided quick answers to questions and offered local recommendations, contributing to a positive guest experience. This direct interaction indicates a commitment to guest satisfaction beyond basic property upkeep.

Alliance Management
Property Management
4
Alliance Management
79.17
Authority
2563 Development Dr, Green Bay, WI 54311

Alliance Management, located at 2563 Development Dr, Green Bay, WI, oversees properties that feature amenities such as pickleball and basketball courts, a clubhouse with a community room, a gym, and a movie theater. Residents also have access to a library. Pet owners will find that pets are permitted, and the surrounding neighborhood dogs are noted as well-behaved. The maintenance team at Howard Commons responded to requests within 24 hours, and snow plowing was completed by 4 am. This community hosts events like summer farmer's markets, weekly entertainment at a pavilion, and offers ice and roller rentals and a splash pad.

Concerns have been raised regarding Alliance Management's handling of accommodation requests for emotional support animals. Documentation provided by a licensed mental health professional, meeting Fair Housing Act requirements, was initially denied. The company cited a repealed state law and made unsubstantiated claims about the invalidity of the provider's credentials. These issues arose despite the provider's active license and direct contact information being present on the documentation.

Following the denial of accommodation requests and subsequent assertions of tenant rights, a security deposit of $5,397.00 was imposed on an unfurnished apartment with a monthly rent of $1,700. This deposit amount exceeds Wisconsin's legal limit of one month's rent for unfurnished units. The timing of this significant deposit demand, occurring only after challenges to the ESA denial, is noted.

Legacy First, LLC
Trusted Advisor
5
Legacy First, LLC
78.05
Authority
304 N Adams St Ste 1, Green Bay, WI 54301

Legacy First, LLC, located at 304 N Adams St Ste 1 in Green Bay, Wisconsin, operates within the property management sector. Clients have noted the individual attention provided by agents, such as Tasha, who manages a focused client base. This approach allows for a personalized experience, with agents open to adapting strategies based on client input and preferences, even integrating clients into the marketing thought process. Tara, another agent, guided clients through both selling existing homes and purchasing new ones, offering direct feedback and managing complex negotiations that exceeded expectations.

First-time homebuyers working with Alexis found her proactive and informative throughout their move from out of state. She addressed questions, explained processes, and facilitated connections to necessary professionals, streamlining the home-buying journey. Alexis's approach eased the stress for those new to purchasing property. The team's knowledge of the Green Bay area was also highlighted by a client relocating back to the region, who appreciated the efficient and supportive process of finding a suitable family home.

A distinct aspect of Legacy First's service is its commitment to community engagement, with a portion of commissions donated to a charity chosen by the client. This practice, along with the team's evident passion for their work and the city, creates a sense of shared investment. While one client reported a lack of finalized contracts and undefined expectations in a past collaboration regarding content support, this appears to be an outlier against generally positive client experiences.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Green Bay

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Green Bay?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Green Bay Real Estate Agents