Best Real Estate Agents
in Indianapolis

We analyzed local market presence, client reviews, and transaction history to find the best real estate agents in Indianapolis.

✓ Real Estate Agents Verified Updated September 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Highgarden Real Estate
8500 Keystone Crossing Ste 170, Indianapolis, IN 4...
Top Agents
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
94.65
2 White Stag Realty
350 Massachusetts Ave #300, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Real Estate
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
90.72
3 REMAX Advanced Realty
8313 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46234
Trusted Realty
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
89.95
4 Martine Locke - Indianapolis REALTOR - @properties
230 E 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Trusted Advisor
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
87.64
5 Steve Lew Real Estate Group
550 US 31 S, Greenwood, IN 46142
Real Estate
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
85.28

Expert Reviews

Highgarden Real Estate
Top Agents
1
Highgarden Real Estate
94.65
Authority
8500 Keystone Crossing Ste 170, Indianapolis, IN 46240

Highgarden Real Estate operates from 8500 Keystone Crossing, Suite 170, in Indianapolis. The team's approach to client relations was noted in one instance where a realtor provided a framed, computer-sketched drawing of the client's family home, inscribed with "The Home that Built a Lifetime of Memories." This gesture was part of the closing process, alongside direct assistance with real estate decisions and timely communication.

Attention to client needs was evident in another account, where an agent conducted thorough virtual tours and inspections for an out-of-state buyer with a short timeline. This included identifying even minor issues within properties, ensuring the client's best interests were considered during a sight-unseen purchase. The agent's role extended to guiding the client through the complexities of remote home acquisition.

The firm's agents also demonstrated a capacity for intricate family relocation projects. One agent assisted multiple family members in securing residences within close proximity to one another, managing the sale of one home and the subsequent purchases of two condominiums. This involved navigating a complex series of transactions to achieve the family's desired living arrangement.

White Stag Realty
Real Estate
2
White Stag Realty
90.72
Authority
350 Massachusetts Ave #300, Indianapolis, IN 46204

White Stag Realty's team members address client needs with focused attention. Cortney worked with individuals searching for property over several months, viewing various types of homes presented. Gurvinder maintained consistent communication throughout a home purchase, promptly answering questions and scheduling viewings, even for unexpected issues.

Greg assisted first-time homebuyers utilizing a USDA loan, explaining each stage of the process. Paul identified a suitable lot for a new construction project for clients living a considerable distance away, arranging a Sunday FaceTime call to share the discovery.

The firm's agents appear to go beyond standard transaction assistance. Kelly Smotherman's clients noted her work made the process smooth and stress-free, leading to the acquisition of a dream home. This dedication extended to anticipating client needs and providing guidance during property acquisition.

REMAX Advanced Realty
Trusted Realty
3
REMAX Advanced Realty
89.95
Authority
8313 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46234

REMAX Advanced Realty's agents in Indianapolis assist clients with real estate transactions. Jade Perry, an agent with the firm, coordinated with an out-of-state client to manage the sale of their house. Perry's efforts to reach an agreement with the client's ex-partner ensured the transaction progressed.

Nate, another agent, worked with a homebuyer who was navigating the process for the first time. He maintained consistent availability for questions and provided explanations of the steps involved. The buyer reported that Nate offered guidance without applying pressure to complete the sale.

Michelle Jackson, a realtor at the agency, supported a client who was selling their home for the first time. Jackson answered the client's questions promptly and managed the negotiation process. Her involvement in the closing phase was noted as contributing to a stress-free experience.

Martine Locke - Indianapolis REALTOR - @properties
Trusted Advisor
4
Martine Locke - Indianapolis REALTOR - @properties
87.64
Authority
230 E 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Martine Locke, located at 230 E 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, assists clients navigating the Indianapolis real estate market. Clients have noted Locke's availability and clarity in guiding them through the process, whether renting, buying, or selling. One client specifically mentioned Locke's attention to detail in identifying potential issues during home viewings.

Locke's approach involves understanding client needs to narrow down searches and present suitable properties. Clients describe her as responsive and knowledgeable, addressing questions promptly and ensuring clear communication throughout transactions. Her professional demeanor extends to managing both purchase and sale processes, aiming for a stress-free experience.

The individualized attention provided by Locke has been a consistent theme among past clients. She manages timelines efficiently and maintains open communication regarding updates and changes. This dedication has led to repeated business from some clients who express confidence in her handling of significant real estate decisions.

Steve Lew Real Estate Group
Real Estate
5
Steve Lew Real Estate Group
85.28
Authority
550 US 31 S, Greenwood, IN 46142

The Steve Lew Real Estate Group, located in Greenwood, Indiana, handles property transactions. They worked with clients selling a log home situated on 12 acres of rural land, with the sale completing in two months from listing in early April. The team's approach to showcasing the property, particularly through photographs, was a factor in its swift sale.

Communication within the group is noted for its clarity and promptness, keeping clients informed throughout the selling process. Steve Lew and his team provided guidance on preparing properties for listing, which assisted clients in meeting their timelines for relocation.

The group has also facilitated first-time homebuyer experiences, with agents offering detailed advice and support. In one instance, an agent spent considerable time assisting a couple in finding a country home, thoroughly inspecting each property with their needs in mind and identifying details the buyers might have missed.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Indianapolis

Looking for Property Managers in Indianapolis?

We've also ranked the best property managers in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Indianapolis Property Managers