Best Real Estate Agents
in Cheektowaga

We analyzed local market presence, client reviews, and transaction history to find the best real estate agents in Cheektowaga.

✓ Real Estate Agents Verified Updated October 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Nichol City Realty
5775 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086
Premier Agent
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
77.84
2 Enas Latif Sales Team - Buffalo Real Estate Agents
5570 Main St Ste 100, Williamsville, NY 14221
Top Agents
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
76.52
3 The Sorrentino Team
5500 Main St #108, Williamsville, NY 14221
Top Agent
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
75.60
4 The Bishop Team at Exp Realty
4830 Transit Rd, Depew, NY 14043
Top Agent
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
71.71
5 Buffalo Home Realty
13295 Broadway, Alden, NY 14004
Top Realtor
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
63.61

Expert Reviews

Nichol City Realty
Premier Agent
1
Nichol City Realty
77.84
Authority
5775 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086

Nichol City Realty, located at 5775 Broadway in Lancaster, NY, offers a focused approach to real estate transactions. The principal, Shannon, brings decades of experience across residential and commercial markets, serving as both a listing and buyers agent. Her background includes navigating the acquisition and sale of multiple residential and commercial properties for her own investment portfolio.

Clients seeking representation find Shannon an approachable guide through the complexities of buying, whether for personal residence or investment. She maintains open communication, providing updates on each stage of the process. Questions are addressed promptly through various means, ensuring clients are informed.

The brokerage's work prioritizes client interests. For those new to homeownership, Shannon offers patient direction. For investors, she shares insights gained from her personal experience to assist in portfolio expansion.

Enas Latif Sales Team - Buffalo Real Estate Agents
Top Agents
2
Enas Latif Sales Team - Buffalo Real Estate Agents
76.52
Authority
5570 Main St Ste 100, Williamsville, NY 14221

The Enas Latif Sales Team operates from Williamsville, NY. Catie Fallon from the team assisted clients with viewings across Western New York, from Rochester to Ransomville, accommodating unscheduled questions and extensive house searches. This team previously managed the sale of a client's home in four days, for a price exceeding the asking amount.

Austyn, another agent with the team, worked with buyers. She addressed client inquiries throughout the homeownership process, offering a composed approach to challenges. Her involvement extended to detailing aspects of preparing a property for market and managing the closing stages. For clients relocating to the area, the team scheduled walkthroughs on short notice, ensuring coverage even when Enas Latif herself was unavailable.

When concerns arose about a property, Enas Latif coordinated with local contractors to obtain repair estimates for clients. She maintained communication during her birthday vacation to negotiate and oversee a successful offer. Austyn supported clients through both buying a new home and selling their existing one, providing insights and managing the process to feel manageable.

The Sorrentino Team
Top Agent
3
The Sorrentino Team
75.60
Authority
5500 Main St #108, Williamsville, NY 14221

The Sorrentino Team in Williamsville, NY, includes agents such as Erica Martone, who has assisted clients with property purchases. One client noted Martone's role in navigating the mortgage process and securing funds when a seller did not fulfill promised repairs. Another reported that Martone dedicated time to understanding their needs before property viewings and made herself available for showings and market analysis upon their relocation.

Jaime Perez, another agent with the team, assisted a client in selling a condominium. This client found the sale process to be agreeable, citing Perez's knowledge and professionalism during a transaction that involved numerous complications. The client expressed gratitude for Perez's assistance in resolving these issues.

Across transactions, clients have mentioned the team's responsiveness. Issues and questions were addressed promptly with detailed information. This promptness was noted even when an agent, Erica Martone, stepped in to show a property at short notice due to another individual's emergency.

The Bishop Team at Exp Realty
Top Agent
4
The Bishop Team at Exp Realty
71.71
Authority
4830 Transit Rd, Depew, NY 14043

The Bishop Team at eXp Realty, located at 4830 Transit Rd in Depew, NY, works with clients in the Cheektowaga area. Their approach involves understanding specific client needs from the outset, as seen when Jamie, a buyer's agent on the team, rearranged her schedule for last-minute showing requests.

Cristin Bishop of the team is noted for a direct approach to selling homes. Her strategy for one property involved a detailed plan, informed by local market knowledge and recent sales data, aiming for broad exposure and buyer engagement. This led to 16 offers on a single house following numerous private showings and open houses.

The team’s communication style is described as frequent and informative, aiming to guide clients through the selling or buying process. Clients mention feeling supported and cared for, with specific instances of the team listening to their vision and helping to secure dream homes. Their responsiveness to questions and concerns is also a frequently cited aspect of their client interactions.

Buffalo Home Realty
Top Realtor
5
Buffalo Home Realty
63.61
Authority
13295 Broadway, Alden, NY 14004

Buffalo Home Realty, located at 13295 Broadway in Alden, NY, provides real estate services within the Cheektowaga area. The team at Buffalo Home Realty is noted for their attentiveness, with one client specifically mentioning their responsiveness and clarity throughout the buying process. This included extensive showings and the handling of necessary arrangements based on stated preferences.

Clients have shared experiences where Anna and Maria, of Buffalo Home Realty, offered guidance during significant life events. This support extended to assisting with the sale of a home during a difficult personal time, with an emphasis on understanding and addressing individual needs. Their approach involved meticulous preparation for potential buyers, facilitating a smoother transition for the seller.

The agency's involvement has also been highlighted in both buying and selling transactions. One account details how Buffalo Home Realty secured a home for a client under budget and under asking price, while simultaneously managing the sale of another property above its asking price. Post-transaction, the team has continued to check in, ensuring clients are settling into their new properties and offering ongoing support for renovations.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Looking for Property Managers in Cheektowaga?

We've also ranked the best property managers in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Cheektowaga Property Managers