Best Property Managers
in Santa Maria

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Santa Maria.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated October 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Kilpelainen Property Management Santa Maria
3535 Mercury Dr, Santa Maria, CA 93455
Trusted Service
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
79.71
2 Williams Bros. Properties
1103 E Clark Ave #A, Santa Maria, CA 93455
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
68.90
3 The Management Trust
2540 Professional Pkwy, Santa Maria, CA 93455
Trusted Partner
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
66.63
4 Haven Property Management
3529 Mercury Dr, Santa Maria, CA 93455
Trusted Manager
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
65.23
5 Advantage Property Management, Inc.
3201 Airpark Dr #209, Santa Maria, CA 93455
Trusted Service
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.2
60.38

Expert Reviews

Kilpelainen Property Management Santa Maria
Trusted Service
1
Kilpelainen Property Management Santa Maria
79.71
Authority
3535 Mercury Dr, Santa Maria, CA 93455

Kilpelainen Property Management, situated at 3535 Mercury Drive in Santa Maria, provides property management services. The company, and specifically an individual named Mika, has been noted for handling rental properties. Mika has been described as personable and works to secure tenants for properties.

Clients have noted Mika's responsiveness throughout application and move-in processes. Communication has been described as prompt and consistent. Questions are addressed, and follow-up is provided in a timely manner.

The property management company offers a resident app, which users found convenient for tasks such as rent payment and maintenance requests. This app has facilitated a smoother rental experience for those who have engaged with Kilpelainen Property Management.

Williams Bros. Properties
Property Management
2
Williams Bros. Properties
68.90
Authority
1103 E Clark Ave #A, Santa Maria, CA 93455

Williams Bros. Properties manages rental residences in Santa Maria, California. The company facilitates the application process for prospective renters, a phase that has been described as quick and easy. Communication channels are maintained to keep those involved updated on relevant property information.

The team at Williams Bros. Properties handles maintenance requests. Tenants have reported that issues are addressed efficiently, with a focus on ensuring resolution without prolonged delays. This responsiveness extends to tenant inquiries and concerns.

Williams Bros. Properties utilizes an online portal for rent payments. The company's representatives are available to assist with move-out procedures, offering support during the transition for departing tenants.

The Management Trust
Trusted Partner
3
The Management Trust
66.63
Authority
2540 Professional Pkwy, Santa Maria, CA 93455

The Management Trust, located at 2540 Professional Parkway in Santa Maria, California, manages community associations. Renee Martinez, a Community Association Manager with the firm, has worked with homeowner associations for several years. Her responsibilities have included addressing long-standing deferred maintenance, responding to homeowner inquiries, and maintaining communication channels.

Martinez has been noted for her professional demeanor and thoroughness in researching board requests. She has provided support to association boards in decision-making processes and managing paperwork. Her approach to coordination has been described as efficient, facilitating the progress of community projects.

The firm's clients have experienced consistent responsiveness from their assigned managers. This has extended to after-hours contact and prompt replies to phone calls and emails. The level of engagement with association matters has been a recurring point of mention by those who have worked with the company.

Haven Property Management
Trusted Manager
4
Haven Property Management
65.23
Authority
3529 Mercury Dr, Santa Maria, CA 93455

Haven Property Management operates from Santa Maria, California. Lisa, associated with the firm, displays a proactive approach to market conditions. Her communication is consistently prompt and clear, addressing concerns for both property owners and renters. She is known to stay informed on pricing and local real estate trends, applying this knowledge to her property management recommendations.

The firm's manager, Lisa, has been noted for her availability and willingness to answer questions thoroughly. Her interactions with clients are described as accommodating and patient, ensuring an understanding of every detail. This approach extends to making the rental or property management process feel straightforward and manageable.

Clients have noted Lisa's ability to remain composed and efficient, even when handling complex situations. Her genuine engagement with the properties she manages is evident, creating a sense of confidence for those she serves. This personal attentiveness is a consistent observation across multiple accounts.

Advantage Property Management, Inc.
Trusted Service
5
Advantage Property Management, Inc.
60.38
Authority
3201 Airpark Dr #209, Santa Maria, CA 93455

Advantage Property Management, Inc. operates from Santa Maria, California. The company has managed properties for individuals who require assistance with rental units and homeownership tasks.

One client noted Tami's involvement in managing their property, stating she exceeded family expectations. This client would not hesitate to hire the company again. Another account highlights a positive experience when moving into a new home, with the company being described as helpful during that process.

A separate client recounted switching from another management company and found Tami's approach reassuring. This client's property was managed after construction, with Tami assisting in coordinating contractors and overseeing the work. The client found the experience removed the burden of property ownership.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Santa Maria?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Santa Maria Real Estate Agents