Best Property Managers
in Cicero

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Cicero.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated October 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 HomeRiver Group Chicago Property Management
600 W Cermak Rd Unit BC1, Chicago, IL 60616
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
90.04
2 Hales Property Management
1411 W Chicago Ave Apt 1, Chicago, IL 60642
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
87.44
3 GC Realty & Development, LLC ®
219 E Irving Park Rd, Roselle, IL 60172
Property Pro
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
85.33
4 Keyrenter Property Management Chicago Metro
1010 Lake St Suite 200, Oak Park, IL 60301
Property Manager
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
82.15
5 Casanomy Property Management
848 W Bartlett Rd Ste 1E, Bartlett, IL 60103
Reliable Choice
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
74.45

Expert Reviews

HomeRiver Group Chicago Property Management
Property Management
1
HomeRiver Group Chicago Property Management
90.04
Authority
600 W Cermak Rd Unit BC1, Chicago, IL 60616

HomeRiver Group Chicago Property Management, located at 600 W Cermak Rd Unit BC1 in Cicero, IL 60616, has managed properties for clients. One client found that work orders submitted by technicians appeared as reviews on the main site, a practice that inflated the company's overall rating.

Communication issues were noted by a tenant who experienced a situation involving mold and swarmers in their unit. Despite submitting multiple work orders for a leak that resulted in wall damage, the issue remained unaddressed for days, with attempts to contact staff leading to dropped calls and unanswered messages. This tenant reported being left without a suitable living space after only a month of residency.

For owners of vacation rentals, HomeRiver Group has taken over bookings, guest communication, and cleaning schedules. One owner reported improved listing performance and increased bookings after the company assisted with optimizing their vacation rental. This specific client noted a single instance of a late check-in that was promptly resolved.

Hales Property Management
Property Management
2
Hales Property Management
87.44
Authority
1411 W Chicago Ave Apt 1, Chicago, IL 60642

Hales Property Management, located at 1411 W Chicago Ave Apt 1, Chicago, IL 60642 in Cicero, has faced scrutiny regarding their customer service. One client reported a history of unclear expectations from building representatives, with service appointments frequently scheduled without prior consultation and at inconvenient times. This individual, working in client services, noted the absence of a basic expectation of clear communication from their service provider.

Conversely, other clients have shared positive interactions. Eduardo, identified as an engineer, has been cited for his contributions to maintaining building cleanliness, odor control, and operational efficiency. John Michael assists with directing communications, and Jazmin, a property manager, is described as consistently pleasant and helpful. Priscilla, another property manager, is recognized for her responsiveness and proactive management of association projects.

In addition to property management, Hales offers brokerage services. Chrissy Gallan is highlighted for her professionalism and detail-oriented approach to real estate sales and transactions. Her ability to adapt to varying client needs and her established network of legal and marketing professionals are noted.

GC Realty & Development, LLC ®
Property Pro
3
GC Realty & Development, LLC ®
85.33
Authority
219 E Irving Park Rd, Roselle, IL 60172

GC Realty & Development, LLC ® in Roselle, IL, handles property management operations. Shania Gilharry is noted for assisting families with issues ranging from maintenance chargebacks to account inquiries, acting with patience and a proactive approach. Catherine Quiroz facilitated apartment applications, providing detailed guidance and prompt communication throughout the process.

The company's service includes managing resident concerns, with clients reporting prompt responses to questions and ongoing information regarding their properties. This focused attention has been a key element for those who have engaged their services.

However, one account details a prolonged period of unresolved issues including significant water leaks and flooding incidents. This reviewer experienced multiple occurrences of standing water and describes the repairs as inadequate over an eleven-month span.

Keyrenter Property Management Chicago Metro
Property Manager
4
Keyrenter Property Management Chicago Metro
82.15
Authority
1010 Lake St Suite 200, Oak Park, IL 60301

Keyrenter Property Management Chicago Metro, located at 1010 Lake St, Suite 200, Oak Park, IL, handles property management for the Chicago metropolitan area. The company's maintenance services focus on identifying necessary repairs, with staff communicating clearly and providing practical solutions.

The tenant acquisition process at Keyrenter Chicago Metro involves an application fee for co-signers, as experienced by one applicant’s clients who paid $276 for co-signer applications. Following two weeks of daily communication, these applications were denied due to the company selecting from five other applicants.

One client expressed gratitude for Mary and her team at Keyrenter, noting their efficiency and professionalism over a 25-year period since their last rental experience. This client felt their property was well-managed and would recommend the company.

Casanomy Property Management
Reliable Choice
5
Casanomy Property Management
74.45
Authority
848 W Bartlett Rd Ste 1E, Bartlett, IL 60103

Casanomy Property Management handles a portfolio that includes subsidized housing, demonstrating familiarity with RHSP units. Their team is known for consistent communication and addressing tenant concerns efficiently, with maintenance requests typically met promptly.

The company facilitates collaborations with contractors for renovations, maintaining a professional approach throughout these projects. Landlords and tenants alike have offered positive remarks regarding Casanomy's operations and the responsiveness of its staff.

For owners managing properties from out of state, Casanomy provides a direct point of contact, overseeing daily operations and unit upkeep. Their approach to tenant relations includes accommodating minor payment delays.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Cicero

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Cicero?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Cicero Real Estate Agents