Best Property Managers
in Rochester

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Rochester.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated September 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Retain Each Property Management
3380 Monroe Ave Ste 207, Rochester, NY 14618
Trusted Manager
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
87.38
2 Retain Each Property Management
275 Lake Ave Ste 155, Rochester, NY 14608
Verified Provider
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
86.58
3 Rochester Property Solutions
212 Winton Rd N, Rochester, NY 14610
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.2
84.43
4 YOURWAY PROPERTIES, Inc.
125 Indigo Creek Dr, Rochester, NY 14626
Property Experts
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
83.00
5 Torres Turn Key Property Management
645 Norton St, Rochester, NY 14621
Highly Rated
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.2
82.76

Expert Reviews

Retain Each Property Management
Trusted Manager
1
Retain Each Property Management
87.38
Authority
3380 Monroe Ave Ste 207, Rochester, NY 14618

Retain Each Property Management in Rochester addresses property oversight with a structured approach. The company facilitates regular communication, with individuals like Donnie noted for consistent updates throughout client interactions. This consistent flow of information aids in managing expectations and maintaining awareness of ongoing property matters.

The team at Retain Each offers a degree of personalized attention. Kerry Ann provided detailed assistance, clarifying information and resolving client inquiries effectively. John also contributed a specific instance of helpfulness and a professional demeanor in client interactions.

A core element of Retain Each's operation involves a collaborative team effort. Annie, Kerry-Ann, Kahalia, Donnie, and Holly are among those who have been identified for thoroughness and helpfulness. This coordinated work across team members contributes to an overall sense of security for property owners.

Retain Each Property Management
Verified Provider
2
Retain Each Property Management
86.58
Authority
275 Lake Ave Ste 155, Rochester, NY 14608

Retain Each Property Management, located at 275 Lake Ave Ste 155 in Rochester, handles property management services. The company interacts with clients through its representatives.

Among its personnel, Kahalia assisted individuals through their home search and rental processes. She demonstrated patience and helpfulness during these interactions. Kelly also played a role in simplifying the rental experience for clients.

Property owners have noted the company's organized and transparent approach. Communication regarding property care and the overall rental process is maintained.

Rochester Property Solutions
Property Management
3
Rochester Property Solutions
84.43
Authority
212 Winton Rd N, Rochester, NY 14610

Rochester Property Solutions manages rental properties at 212 Winton Rd N, Rochester, NY 14610. The agency facilitates the leasing process, with staff members such as Caroline offering assistance throughout the move-in. Some residents report apartments equipped with modern features like keyless entry and new appliances.

Maintenance is a key area of their operations. When repair requests are submitted, the maintenance team communicates progress and addresses issues. Technicians like Pete have been noted for resolving multiple requests to tenant satisfaction. Dean is also mentioned for his professionalism and attention to detail in managing maintenance tasks.

Instances of properties requiring cleaning and repairs prior to resident move-in have occurred. This includes issues with garages filled with previous tenant belongings and a lack of clear access points to the front or back doors. Some prospective tenants have also experienced a lack of communication regarding their application status.

YOURWAY PROPERTIES, Inc.
Property Experts
4
YOURWAY PROPERTIES, Inc.
83.00
Authority
125 Indigo Creek Dr, Rochester, NY 14626

YOURWAY PROPERTIES, Inc. manages rental properties from their office at 125 Indigo Creek Dr in Rochester. The company's team handles various aspects of property management. They have a history of addressing tenant issues promptly, with one instance cited where a problem was resolved within a day.

The associates at YOURWAY PROPERTIES, Inc. offer a thorough approach to tenant placement. They provide lists of qualified candidates, allowing property owners to select suitable individuals. This service assists individuals who may not have the time to manage the tenant screening process personally.

Communication appears to be a focal point for YOURWAY PROPERTIES, Inc. They are described as professional and knowledgeable in their dealings. Their responsiveness facilitates the management of rental properties, catering to the needs of residents, owners, and regulatory bodies.

Torres Turn Key Property Management
Highly Rated
5
Torres Turn Key Property Management
82.76
Authority
645 Norton St, Rochester, NY 14621

Torres Turn Key Property Management operates from 645 Norton St, Rochester, NY. One client noted a significant issue with the installation of light fixtures, where electrical tape was used instead of proper wiring connections, creating a potential safety hazard. Another past homeowner reported that for over two years, rent payments were inconsistent, with tenants at times falling more than two months behind. During this period, water bills were also not paid, and these issues were not proactively communicated by the management team.

The renovation work performed in 2021 for a client’s rental property involved new flooring, paint, and light fixtures, costing approximately $10,000. Post-termination of their contract, the homeowner discovered baseboards and floorboards cut short of the wall length and outlets and switches painted over. This same client mentioned a situation where rent was not received for two months in November 2022, with assurances that the tenant would renew their lease, though follow-up indicated ongoing payment issues.

In contrast, another individual found the team helpful when moving into a new home, describing the process as efficient and thorough, with questions addressed patiently. This person also reported a smooth and pleasant experience during their move. For clients seeking assistance with initial property setup, the team has arranged property viewings and identified suitable options with competitive pricing.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Rochester

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Rochester?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Rochester Real Estate Agents