Best Property Managers in
Pennsylvania

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Pennsylvania to find the absolute elite Property Managers destinations.

Average Authority Score
69.1
across all ranked locations
Top-Rated City
Philadelphia
highest avg. score in Pennsylvania
Verified Locations
40
businesses confirmed active
Cities Ranked
2
Philadelphia · Pittsburgh

Pennsylvania Hall of Fame

Otter Property Management
State Elite
1
Otter Property Management
95.28
Authority
1728 Ridge Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19130

Otter Property Management's tenancy began with a property unprepared for occupancy, featuring dead pests, significant dust, mold in toilets, and non-functional refrigerator components. Security was also an immediate concern, with only one key provided for a four-person household and a promised smart lock replacement failing to materialize over a year later. Billing inconsistencies were prevalent, including charges for utilities used prior to the tenant's move-in date and a protracted five-month period to explain a single bill.

A refrigerator repair billed at over $800 was not successfully completed, yet the charge and associated late fees were refused removal. Following a negative review, Otter Property Management offered to rectify maintenance and billing issues, including replacing locks and waiving over $900 in disputed charges, contingent on the tenant deleting their feedback and signing a lease renewal. This offer was declined. Upon the tenant's departure, unresolved security and ledger issues persisted.

Further complications arose when Otter Property Management reported the tenant's rent as "late" or "partially paid" to screening agencies, despite consistent on-time payment of base rent via autopay. Only disputed utility and repair fees remained unpaid, having been immediately challenged in writing. This created a discrepancy where management offered lease renewals while concurrently submitting negative rental history to agencies.

Lobos Management
State Elite
2
Lobos Management
93.00
Authority
233 Spahr St, Pittsburgh, PA 15232

Lobos Management handles property inquiries with a notable attention to individual needs. Chloe Jones, in particular, assisted one client through two separate lease agreements, locating affordable studio apartments and guiding them through the application process for a subsequent move. She answered questions promptly and offered reassurance during potential application complications, even reaching out on her day off to confirm a lease acceptance. Bailey, another staff member, also worked with prospective renters, showing apartments and explaining lease details, maintaining communication when questions arose. Mackenzie’s approach involved showing multiple units and offering further assistance the following day when initial searches did not yield a suitable outcome.

The administrative process at Lobos Management, as experienced during a visit for a parking pass, involved a collaborative team. Sarah, AJ, Bailey, and Marisa were present, with Audrey noted for her ability to manage multiple clients when the office became busy. This interaction provided a smooth experience for the client picking up their pass. For those touring apartments, such as Royal Windsor, staff like Bailey presented units accurately, with descriptions aligning with online listings.

Prospective residents have reported that Lobos Management staff, including Chloe and Bailey, are responsive to inquiries regarding apartment details and lease terms. They aim to match individuals with suitable living spaces in desired neighborhoods. The team's ability to address specific requirements and provide clear, transparent information contributes to their client interactions.

Bay Property Management Group Philadelphia
State Elite
3
Bay Property Management Group Philadelphia
92.55
Authority
1080 N Delaware Ave #506, Philadelphia, PA 19125

Bay Property Management Group Philadelphia is located at 1080 N Delaware Ave #506. The firm's approach to property oversight includes attentive handling of tenant concerns, such as a broken refrigerator requiring replacement. Property managers have been noted for their patience and clear communication throughout these situations.

Tenants and property owners have reported consistent responsiveness from the management team. Communication methods vary, with some interactions occurring solely through email, while others involve direct dialogue. This includes proactive updates on property matters, sometimes accompanied by visual documentation.

During the transition of rental property management to Bay Property Management Group, specific individuals were assigned to accounts. These assignments resulted in prompt communication with both property owners and tenants, leading to observable improvements in service.

TrustArt Realty
State Elite
4
TrustArt Realty
92.38
Authority
1101 Foulkrod St, Philadelphia, PA 19124

TrustArt Realty manages properties at 1101 Foulkrod St, Philadelphia. The company handles maintenance requests with efficiency, dispatching technicians promptly. Issues such as HVAC system repairs are addressed within hours, with communication maintained throughout the process.

The team's approach to property management includes a focus on client assets and team development. Individuals working with TrustArt Realty have noted the ease of switching from other management services. Properties listed with them tend to rent quickly.

Communication regarding property status is provided consistently. Loraine, a member of the team, has been recognized for facilitating ease of work for roofing contractors through her communication.

PhillyLiving Management Group
State Elite
5
PhillyLiving Management Group
91.36
Authority
2401 Walnut St #201, Philadelphia, PA 19103

PhillyLiving Management Group, located at 2401 Walnut St #201, Philadelphia, PA 19103, has a property manager, Mike Gordon, who navigated a complicated lease for one couple, breaking down complex contract terms for their understanding. Gordon maintained consistent availability, responding promptly to inquiries and scheduling viewings efficiently, which streamlined the apartment search for a family relocating from out of town. He presented rental options in a logical geographic sequence during a single weekend of showings.

Gordon facilitated a swift application process when a promising apartment was identified, recognizing the urgency of a first-come, first-served system. His support extended beyond the transaction; he assisted a tenant with moving a delivered couch into their new apartment. This willingness to assist with tasks not directly related to the rental agreement provided a notable level of personal engagement.

The interactions with Gordon have consistently involved swift responses to questions, scheduling requests, and advice. His approach involved understanding individual needs and proactively suggesting suitable properties. This methodical handling of the rental process contributed to a smooth and unhurried experience for those he assisted.

City Directory

Switch to Real Estate Agents in Pennsylvania

We also track and rank the top real estate agents providers across Pennsylvania.

View Pennsylvania Real Estate Agents