Best Property Managers
in Sacramento

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Sacramento.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated September 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Keyrenter Sacramento Property Management
6524 Lonetree Blvd, Rocklin, CA 95765
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
92.03
2 Legacy Property Management
2143 Hurley Way Suite 103, Sacramento, CA 95825
Property Manager
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
92.00
3 PMI American River
1100 11th St Ste 305, Sacramento, CA 95814
Property Pro
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
89.30
4 Utopia Property Management | Sacramento, CA
2601 Capitol Ave, Sacramento, CA 95816
Property Excellence
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
87.99
5 River Valley Property Management
180 Promenade Cir Ste 300, Sacramento, CA 95834
Highly Recommended
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
84.03

Expert Reviews

Keyrenter Sacramento Property Management
Property Management
1
Keyrenter Sacramento Property Management
92.03
Authority
6524 Lonetree Blvd, Rocklin, CA 95765

Keyrenter Sacramento Property Management, located at 6524 Lonetree Blvd in Rocklin, CA, manages properties in the Sacramento area. During a property walkthrough, a representative thoroughly explained all aspects of the home, ensuring a feeling of informed comfort. The team, including Liz and Amanda, has provided consistent support and answered tenant questions throughout the application and move-in process.

Staff members have addressed property maintenance tasks promptly, securing additional assistance when immediate resolutions were not feasible. This proactive approach facilitated a smooth transition for residents, with ongoing support available even after receiving keys. Communication and care are consistent aspects of their client interactions.

Liz, in particular, has been noted for her professionalism and responsiveness. When other representatives were unavailable, she readily offered assistance, listened carefully to concerns, and provided insightful expertise. Her initiative and clear communication are valued by those who work with her.

Legacy Property Management
Property Manager
2
Legacy Property Management
92.00
Authority
2143 Hurley Way Suite 103, Sacramento, CA 95825

Legacy Property Management in Sacramento has handled property rental for clients. Nataly and Jonathan are noted for their communication during management transitions and ongoing responsiveness. Scott provided specific repairs, replacing a gate latch and adding a metal pull loop to a backyard gate, which subsequently allowed the gate to close securely.

One client experienced issues with initial property listing, with the property priced approximately $600 below market value, leading to numerous applicants. This client also reported a property manager, Loren, did not include requested terms in the rental contract, resulting in extra financial liability. Loren also withheld thermostat sensors, which the client stated led to a service call for a non-existent issue, and failed to inspect requested items during a house inspection. This client also noted an improper response to an HOA citation and lost keys for five sets of French doors. Subsequent communication attempts by this client were reportedly ignored.

Another reviewer found the rental process involved numerous fees and the assigned property was priced above comparable listings in the area, including additional utilities not present in other units within the same complex. This individual expressed doubt about the authenticity of positive reviews.

PMI American River
Property Pro
3
PMI American River
89.30
Authority
1100 11th St Ste 305, Sacramento, CA 95814

PMI American River handles property management from their Sacramento office. They engage specialized professional services for repairs, a detail noted by a homeowner who experienced a plumbing emergency. This approach contrasts with a single maintenance person handling all issues across properties.

The company's responsiveness is a consistent theme. In one instance, a property was re-rented within a week after a tenant broke their lease, with PMI managing the process entirely for the owner. Communication appears to be a priority, with questions frequently answered within hours.

PMI American River manages rental properties, facilitating tenant relations and day-to-day operations. They attend to property upkeep, with one client specifically mentioning attention to detail regarding the appearance and maintenance of their home.

Utopia Property Management | Sacramento, CA
Property Excellence
4
Utopia Property Management | Sacramento, CA
87.99
Authority
2601 Capitol Ave, Sacramento, CA 95816

Utopia Property Management in Sacramento offers a property management experience characterized by a systematic approach to resident onboarding. The digital handling of paperwork prior to move-in and the prompt availability of keys contribute to a structured entry into new residences. Information necessary for settling in is provided by the staff, ensuring a clear understanding of the premises.

Camille, a representative at Utopia Sacramento, is noted for her attentive client interactions. She addresses resident inquiries with thoroughness, managing details from initial contact through ongoing tenancy. Her communication style is described as clear and professional, facilitating understanding of updates and necessary actions. Maintenance requests are acknowledged promptly and are followed through to resolution.

The property management firm dispatches service technicians who conduct themselves professionally during site visits. These technicians arrive punctually, explain the work to be performed, and execute repairs with care. They also provide explanations of the issues encountered and their resolutions, fostering a sense of trust and respect within the home.

River Valley Property Management
Highly Recommended
5
River Valley Property Management
84.03
Authority
180 Promenade Cir Ste 300, Sacramento, CA 95834

River Valley Property Management facilitates rental processes with a notable emphasis on consistent tenant support. AJ served as a primary point of contact for one client, whose experience involved responsiveness and preparedness throughout the rental application and lease execution. This individual noted AJ's direct communication style and organization during property tours.

Leisa Wells is frequently cited for her involvement with tenants, with one reviewer highlighting her communication as exceptional, often extending beyond standard business hours. This same reviewer observed Leisa's ability to manage the stress often associated with finding a new home, approaching the task with what was described as grace and empathy. The ease of the move-in process and prompt attention to maintenance requests are also recurring themes in tenant feedback concerning the team.

The company utilizes an online platform and app designed for rent payment, communication, and maintenance requests. This digital interface is described as simple, organized, and efficient by those who have used it over extended rental periods. The family-owned nature of the business is mentioned by multiple tenants, who express satisfaction with the overall management of their properties.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Sacramento

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Sacramento?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Sacramento Real Estate Agents