Best Property Managers
in Lexington

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Lexington.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated September 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 PURE HomeRiver Property Management of Kentucky
250 E Short St #320, Lexington, KY 40507
Mixed Results
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
89.00
2 Modern Property Management Inc
1501 N Limestone, Lexington, KY 40505
Property Partner
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
84.06
3 Top Shelf Property Management
1795 Alysheba Way Unit 7105, Lexington, KY 40509
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
81.64
4 Freedom Realty and Property Management
624 W Lexington Ave, Winchester, KY 40391
Property Experts
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
79.60
5 Baughman Property Management, LLC
1999 Richmond Rd #200, Lexington, KY 40502
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
73.58

Expert Reviews

PURE HomeRiver Property Management of Kentucky
Mixed Results
1
PURE HomeRiver Property Management of Kentucky
89.00
Authority
250 E Short St #320, Lexington, KY 40507

PURE HomeRiver Property Management of Kentucky offers a mixed record of tenant and owner experiences. Some prospective tenants have found the initial setup process streamlined, with individual agents like Alex Britton noted for answering questions and facilitating a smooth transition. For those already residing in PURE-managed properties, the duration of their tenancy has sometimes been long, indicating a stable living environment.

However, the process of renting a property through PURE can present significant hurdles. Potential renters have described difficulty in understanding property availability statuses on the website and have encountered communication loops that lead back to the website or general office lines, rather than providing direct assistance. Scheduling viewings and gaining entry can be complicated, with unclear instructions and unexpected barriers, such as access codes not functioning or specific contact personnel being unavailable or misidentified.

For property owners, the year-long engagement with PURE HomeRiver Property Management of Kentucky resulted in a high turnover of tenants, leading to repeated vacancies, financial strain, and extensive wear and tear on the property. Issues ranged from unexplained utility bills to significant repair needs and prolonged periods without rental income. Communication with management during critical events, particularly when a primary contact was absent, left some owners feeling uninformed and unsupported, with their insurance provider offering more reassurance than the management team itself.

Modern Property Management Inc
Property Partner
2
Modern Property Management Inc
84.06
Authority
1501 N Limestone, Lexington, KY 40505

Modern Property Management Inc. at 1501 N Limestone, Lexington, KY 40505, offers a structured approach to property oversight. The company handles property listing, tenant screening, and legal considerations for those converting residences to rental properties. Their team maintains a network of contractors, including plumbers and electricians, for property upkeep.

Communication appears to be a cornerstone of their operations, with timely responses to inquiries and prompt notification of any issues. Documentation, including forms and reports, is consistently completed and submitted without delay. Repairs identified during initial property assessments are addressed prior to subsequent showings.

The management and maintenance teams at Modern Property Management Inc. have facilitated smooth transitions for residents, including assistance with lockouts and addressing immediate repair needs. Electronic lease completion and a resident portal for payments contribute to an efficient process for those leasing properties.

Top Shelf Property Management
Property Management
3
Top Shelf Property Management
81.64
Authority
1795 Alysheba Way Unit 7105, Lexington, KY 40509

Top Shelf Property Management, located at 1795 Alysheba Way Unit 7105 in Lexington, KY, handles property management services for the Lexington area. The firm's approach includes addressing prior tenant issues for owners, even when those tenants were not initially placed by Top Shelf. Their operations have been noted for bringing stability to properties that experienced frequent tenant turnover and damage under previous management.

In cases of property unlivability, their team, particularly Kathy, has assisted residents in finding new housing. This assistance has extended to facilitating faster move-ins and negotiating fees. One account details Kathy personally covering hotel costs for a displaced resident while repairs were underway. This level of personal intervention has been observed during stressful situations, providing tangible support.

Conversely, some former renters have reported issues concerning communication and financial matters. These accounts mention significant rent increases without prior notification and disputes over deposit usage. One tenant described needing to provide documentation and involve multiple parties to clarify lease terms.

Freedom Realty and Property Management
Property Experts
4
Freedom Realty and Property Management
79.60
Authority
624 W Lexington Ave, Winchester, KY 40391

Freedom Realty and Property Management operates from 624 W Lexington Ave in Winchester, KY. Their approach to property management is characterized by a focused team. The individuals handling transactions, specifically Greg and Josh, have been noted for their extensive knowledge of the local market and attention to detail. Their management of the sales process, from initial suggestions on property presentation to negotiation, has been a consistent point of observation by clients.

Clients have reported that Freedom Realty guided them through the complexities of property sales. The team's ability to accurately represent property assets online and in descriptions has been a recurring detail. This attention to presentation and market understanding has often coincided with rapid sales, sometimes occurring within a single day and often with multiple offers exceeding the initial asking price.

The firm's client interactions are frequently described as professional and direct. There is a clear emphasis on objective setting and addressing client inquiries efficiently. This hands-on management style has fostered a sense of close working relationships with those they represent.

Baughman Property Management, LLC
Property Management
5
Baughman Property Management, LLC
73.58
Authority
1999 Richmond Rd #200, Lexington, KY 40502

Baughman Property Management manages residences in Lexington, Kentucky, with a focus on proximity to the University of Kentucky. One tenant lived in a Baughman Property studio on South Limestone for a year, noting its convenience for UK students with classes directly across the street. This individual also highlighted the pet-friendly nature of the property.

Communication with management is a consistent point of feedback. Kim, a central figure in the company, is frequently mentioned as being accessible and easy to contact. Several residents report that maintenance requests were handled with speed and efficiency. Properties managed by the company are described as comfortable and well-maintained.

The pricing of the apartments is a recurring theme in resident accounts, often described as reasonable or a good deal when considering the location and amenities. One tenant, who moved out of an apartment to find a larger place, still referred to the owner, Kim, as "by the best property owner" they had ever encountered due to her helpfulness and personable nature.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Lexington

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Lexington?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Lexington Real Estate Agents