Best Property Managers
in Columbus

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Columbus.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated September 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 RL Property Management
750 Cross Pointe Rd Suite B, Columbus, OH 43230
Trusted Service
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.3
89.89
2 Stratagem Management
172 E 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
Property Managers
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.1
88.25
3 Grand Welcome Columbus Property Management
570 Polaris Pkwy Ste 400a, Westerville, OH 43082
Highly Recommended
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
87.85
4 7rent.com Rental Property Management & Realty Columbus
334 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
Trusted Manager
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
87.05
5 Sentry Management, Inc.
4249 Easton Way #220, Columbus, OH 43219
Top Provider
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.3
81.83

Expert Reviews

RL Property Management
Trusted Service
1
RL Property Management
89.89
Authority
750 Cross Pointe Rd Suite B, Columbus, OH 43230

RL Property Management, located at 750 Cross Pointe Rd Suite B, Columbus, OH 43230, has provided services to homeowners. One inspector, Drea, identified a lack of smoke detectors in three bedrooms and scheduled an appointment to ensure their installation. Another client noted that an inspector explained the inspection process clearly and assisted with resolving an issue concerning a garbage disposal.

Interaction with the application process presented initial challenges. A prospective tenant experienced delays in receiving assistance with an online application, despite repeated attempts to contact the company via multiple channels. This led to a concern about responsiveness.

The company's property management services have been positively reviewed by clients who have worked with specific managers. Lauren Begley was described as professional, efficient, and courteous. Michael Short also received commendation for his work managing multiple properties.

Stratagem Management
Property Managers
2
Stratagem Management
88.25
Authority
172 E 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43201

Stratagem Management handles properties in Columbus, Ohio. The company facilitated a move between apartments for one resident, beginning with assurances of a flexible timeline. This was followed by communication of shifting deadlines for vacating the initial unit, culminating in a 24-hour notice on a Monday to move all possessions. The resident reported the air conditioning in the new unit failed on a Thursday, with subsequent communication indicating the issue was not considered an emergency by the Columbus office, leading to a five-day period without functional AC. Inquiries to higher-ups, identified as Taylor Moore and leasing managers, resulted in speaking with different agents and difficulty obtaining updates.

Other experiences with Stratagem Management detail a positive interaction with leasing manager Sam, who assisted a resident in finding a new home after initial options were unavailable. This resident noted Sam’s dedication in staying in contact and providing suitable alternatives. Maintenance support was also highlighted by a resident whose shower spout and head malfunctioned; Alan responded promptly and resolved the issue with a positive demeanor, also addressing other mentioned concerns. Another resident described a smooth signing process with leasing manager Sam and a quick resolution to a minor work order by maintenance staff member Alan.

However, one former resident detailed issues during a 4.5-year tenancy at 106 East 13th Avenue. This individual experienced repeated erroneous duplicate fee charges on billing statements, requiring direct intervention to rectify. The move-out process was described as disappointing, with a significant portion of the security deposit not returned and no explanation provided despite follow-ups. Safety concerns were raised, including the theft of vehicle wheels and rims. While initial maintenance was responsive, its quality declined, with some staff appearing unskilled and one individual described as aggressive. Frequent noise from undergraduate students was also noted as a concern.

Grand Welcome Columbus Property Management
Highly Recommended
3
Grand Welcome Columbus Property Management
87.85
Authority
570 Polaris Pkwy Ste 400a, Westerville, OH 43082

Grand Welcome Columbus Property Management offers a property at 570 Polaris Pkwy Ste 400a in Westerville that provides a well-equipped kitchen and comfortable memory foam beds. Ceiling fans are present throughout, and the air conditioning functions effectively. A picnic table is available on the outdoor space.

The property's location is noted as being at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, contributing to a peaceful atmosphere. A local coffee shop is accessible within a short drive. The interior is described as spotless and well-maintained, with a living room sofa that enhances comfort.

The home includes a garage space with a pool table and game system, kept comfortable by a window air conditioning unit. A large dining table accommodates groups, and new, quiet washer and dryer units are present.

7rent.com Rental Property Management & Realty Columbus
Trusted Manager
4
7rent.com Rental Property Management & Realty Columbus
87.05
Authority
334 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201

7rent.com Rental Property Management & Realty Columbus manages properties with a focus on timely repairs and property upkeep. Maintenance issues are addressed promptly, with immediate replacement of necessary parts rather than temporary fixes. Upon move-in, residences are noted for their exceptional cleanliness, a detail that distinguishes them from the standard "landlord special."

Communication with the management team is straightforward, facilitating a less complicated rental experience. The properties are described as well-kept and situated in desirable locations, with specific mention of proximity to The Oval and Ohio Stadium, making them convenient for those affiliated with Ohio State University. Tenants have reported long-term satisfaction, staying for multiple years.

The team's responsiveness extends to tenant inquiries and concerns, with a consistent pattern of quick responses. This attention to detail and tenant well-being has led to a positive reputation among renters, particularly for those seeking off-campus housing near the university.

Sentry Management, Inc.
Top Provider
5
Sentry Management, Inc.
81.83
Authority
4249 Easton Way #220, Columbus, OH 43219

Sentry Management, Inc., located at 4249 Easton Way #220 in Columbus, Ohio, engages in property management services. The company's representatives have facilitated the completion of work on condominium communities, with one vendor noting Margo’s diligent communication with the Board, Owners, and their company regarding a recent project. Another client reported an initial delay in response to online work orders, necessitating a follow-up call to Felicia, who then approved the first work order.

Jeff McCrobie, a community manager for Sentry, has managed a neighborhood for the past year. His work has involved consistent communication and follow-up with both the Board and homeowners. Jeff has kept residents informed about vendor bids, project progress, and scheduling for on-site work.

Millie, an inside representative for Sentry, responded promptly to calls and emails concerning a condominium issue, arranging for a technician. Rob, the technician, addressed the problem efficiently, completing the work to a high standard. Sherry, a Community Manager, is noted for her professionalism and responsiveness in assisting community members.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Columbus

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Columbus?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Columbus Real Estate Agents