Best Property Managers
in Louisville

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Louisville.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated September 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 LREI PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC
815 Ulrich Ave, Louisville, KY 40219
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
92.06
2 Kentuckiana Property Management LLC
3240 Office Pointe Pl Ste 102, Louisville, KY 4022...
Exceptional Service
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
91.58
3 Sharon Landrum Realty, Inc.
721 S 8th St Ste a, Louisville, KY 40203
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
90.36
4 Robert Massey Company
2101 Wrocklage Ave, Louisville, KY 40205
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
89.27
5 Property Management of Louisville & PML Real Estate Group
1815 Frankfort Ave, Louisville, KY 40206
Quality Service
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.1
89.27

Expert Reviews

LREI PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC
Property Management
1
LREI PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC
92.06
Authority
815 Ulrich Ave, Louisville, KY 40219

LREI Property Management LLC in Louisville has been associated with properties experiencing prolonged maintenance issues, specifically a two-year tenancy where a unit's air conditioning remained unrepaired for approximately seven months. During this period, residents reported apartment temperatures reaching the upper 80s and low 90s, with no temporary cooling solutions provided. Following the HVAC repair, a large hole in the ceiling with exposed wiring remained for about a month, pending owner approval.

Upon moving out, residents faced unexpected charges totaling close to $1,000. These included a $500 painting fee attributed to what was considered ordinary wear and tear after two years, professional cleaning charges despite a hired cleaning service, and fees for inexpensive items such as a light bulb and drip pans. Many of these charges corresponded to issues previously reported during tenancy or maintenance problems that existed during their residency, which proved difficult to resolve directly with management.

Inquiries into properties managed by LREI have also raised concerns regarding upfront financial demands and inconsistent rental offers. Potential renters have been asked for payment and utility setup before lease signing, and in one instance, a offered reduced rent was rescinded. A viewing of an alternative property revealed significant disrepair, including rodent droppings and damaged fixtures, with descriptions not matching online photographs.

Kentuckiana Property Management LLC
Exceptional Service
2
Kentuckiana Property Management LLC
91.58
Authority
3240 Office Pointe Pl Ste 102, Louisville, KY 40220

Kentuckiana Property Management LLC engages with communities through its representatives, such as Amber Justice, who attends HOA meetings and handles resident inquiries. This approach provides a direct line of communication for community matters, ensuring that issues are addressed. The company's leasing agent, Liz, has facilitated the placement of qualified tenants in properties, often within a week of units becoming vacant.

The firm's approach to property management involves assigning community managers, like April, who provide thorough and knowledgeable service. Residents report positive interactions with office staff when calling the company, noting courtesy and respect from all individuals encountered. Travis, the owner, also interacts with clients, with a stated dedication to his work.

Interactions with Kentuckiana Property Management personnel are characterized by their accessibility and dedication. Liz, the leasing agent, makes herself available for showings outside of standard business hours, accommodating prospective tenants' schedules. This consistent availability aids in maintaining the momentum of the leasing process.

Sharon Landrum Realty, Inc.
Property Management
3
Sharon Landrum Realty, Inc.
90.36
Authority
721 S 8th St Ste a, Louisville, KY 40203

Sharon Landrum Realty, Inc. manages properties in Louisville, with a focus on historic buildings. Tenants have noted prompt response times for maintenance, with some staff, including Preston and Bobby, arriving within an hour to address issues. Ken from pest control has provided same-day service, working outside business hours and offering helpful advice.

Some tenants have experienced extensive delays and significant issues with property upkeep. Reports mention neglected properties with problems like black mold and faulty electrical wiring. Tenant interactions with office staff have also been described as difficult, with a perception that the company prioritizes profit over resident well-being.

Experiences with tenant placement and property oversight have varied. One property owner reported being charged for unjustified maintenance requests and issues arising from tenant selection. The company's handling of a tenant's removal of a security system also drew criticism.

Robert Massey Company
Property Management
4
Robert Massey Company
89.27
Authority
2101 Wrocklage Ave, Louisville, KY 40205

The Robert Massey Company manages properties at 2101 Wrocklage Ave, Louisville, KY 40205. Gloria has been noted for facilitating smooth move-in processes, assisting with a quick turnaround on lease agreements. Daniel has addressed maintenance requests promptly and professionally, making a noticeable improvement in tenant experience compared to prior management.

The company's operational efficiency stands out, with one tenant describing their experience as streamlined and stress-free. Maintenance issues have seen swift resolutions, contributing to a positive outlook for current residents.

However, concerns have been raised regarding the return of security deposits. One account indicates that thorough cleaning and documented repairs during tenancy were insufficient to reclaim the full deposit, with the company ultimately siding with the landlord.

Property Management of Louisville & PML Real Estate Group
Quality Service
5
Property Management of Louisville & PML Real Estate Group
89.27
Authority
1815 Frankfort Ave, Louisville, KY 40206

Property Management of Louisville & PML Real Estate Group manages properties from their base at 1815 Frankfort Ave in Louisville. The firm's approach involves responding to tenant needs directly. Recent tenant feedback notes that BJ addressed a toilet seat repair and also examined a gas oven, completing tasks efficiently.

The company's maintenance personnel are frequently mentioned in tenant accounts. Tim Payton, for instance, attended a property on two occasions, addressing a kitchen faucet replacement. He maintained a pleasant demeanor while handling tenant concerns, according to one resident. Another resident reported that Sam, Joe, and BJ were punctual and resolved all issues without leaving any disarray.

For residents who experienced a change in management, Property Management of Louisville has been noted as a significant upgrade. Maintenance requests have seen prompt attention; B.J. arrived the day after a request was submitted to resolve an issue, completing the work swiftly and courteously. This level of direct and effective service from their team has been a recurring theme in tenant comments.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Louisville?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Louisville Real Estate Agents